Epidemiology of coinfection with soil transmitted helminths and Plasmodium falciparum among school children in Bumula District in western Kenya

Abstract

Background

Many school children living in Africa are infected with plasmodia and helminth species and are consequently at risk of coinfection. However, the epidemiology of such coinfection and the implications of coinfection for children’s health remain poorly understood. This study describes the epidemiology of Ascaris lumbricoides-Plasmodium and hookworm-Plasmodium coinfection among school children living in western Kenya and investigates the associated risk factors.

Methods

As part of a randomized trial, a baseline cross-sectional survey was conducted among school children aged 5–18 years in 23 schools in Bumula District. Single stool samples were collected to screen for helminth infections using the Kato-Katz technique and malaria parasitaemia was determined from a finger prick blood sample. Demographic and anthropometric data were also collected.

Results

Overall, 46.4 % of the children were infected with Plasmodium falciparum while 27.6 % of the children were infected with at least one soil transmitted helminth (STH) species, with hookworm being the most common (16.8 %) followed by A. lumbricoides (15.3 %). Overall 14.3 % of the children had STH-Plasmodium coinfection, with hookworm-Plasmodium (9.0 %) coinfection being the most common. Geographical variation in the prevalence of coinfection occurred between schools. In multivariable logistic regression analysis, hookworm was positively associated with P. falciparum infection. In stratified analysis, hookworm infection was associated with increased odds of P. falciparum infection among both boys (P < 0.001) and girls (P = 0.01), whereas there was no association between A. lumbricoides and P. falciparum.

Conclusion

These findings demonstrate STH infections are still prevalent, despite the ongoing national deworming programme in Kenya, and that malaria parasitaemia is widespread, such that coinfection occurs among a proportion of children. A subsequent trial will allow us to investigate the implications of coinfection for the risk of clinical malaria.

Background

School children living in sub-Saharan Africa are commonly infected with helminth and plasmodia species, with many children harbouring multiple infections. For example, studies in east and west Africa indicate that between 13.5 % and 60 % of school children are concurrently infected with Plasmodium falciparum and different soil-transmitted helminth species [1–11]. Helminths are known to invoke strong immune responses [12] and it has been suggested that they affect malaria-specific immune responses which may, in turn, alter the risks of malaria parasitaemia and clinical disease [12, 13]. The occurrence of coinfection will also influence the planning of integrated intervention strategies that simultaneously tackle helminth infections and malaria [14]. Despite the growing awareness of the issue of helminth-plasmodia coinfection, there are few detailed and comprehensive data on coinfection and putative risk factors. Previous work in Kenya has shown that coinfection is more common among boys, is less common with increasing age, and highest among children from the poorest households [3, 4]. Other work in Côte d’Ivoire confirms that boys and children from poorer households are at greater risk of coinfection with soil transmitted helminths and Plasmodium spp. [9, 11]. The risk of coinfection is also associated with access to sanitation and clean water, recent deworming, and living in urban settings [3, 9]. Studies have in addition highlighted the marked spatial heterogeneity in the distribution of helminth-coinfection at both local and regional scales [3, 4, 8]. In this paper we describe results from school surveys carried out in Bumula District, western Kenya, conducted as part of screening surveys for an individually randomized trial investigating the impact of intensive anthelminthic treatment versus annual treatment on the risk of clinical malaria among school children in Bumula District, western Kenya (ClinicalTrials.gov NCT01658774). The aim of the present analysis is to describe the patterns of Ascaris-Plasmodium and hookworm-Plasmodium coinfection and investigate whether helminth species infection are associated with Plasmodium infection.

Methods

Study setting

The survey was conducted in Bumula District which is one of the sub-counties in Bungoma County, western Kenya, between February and June 2013. Bumula District is located at 1,320 m elevation and experiences an annual average rainfall of 2,428 mm, with the long rains occurring from March-May and short rains from October-December. Average annual minimum and maximum temperatures are 11 °C and 24 °C, respectively. The population of the area consists of indigenous Bukusu, a subtribe of the Luhya community. The economy is primarily rural subsistence agriculture, with some families growing sugar cane as a cash crop. The population is serviced by Bumula Sub-District Hospital, which serves about 180,000 people and a catchment area of approximately 250 km².

The area was chosen because it experiences a high rate of malaria transmission and some of the highest prevalences of STH in Kenya [15, 16]. Malaria transmission is intense and perennial, with two seasonal peaks (April-June and November-December), and most malaria is caused by P. falciparum. Recent survey data indicated the prevalence of P. falciparum as 21.6 % [16]. Historically, helminth infections were highly prevalent in the area [17], but improvements in socioeconomic status and access to water and sanitation has reduced infection levels [18]. A national school-based deworming programme launched in 2009 and more recent data indicate that 25.1 % of school children are estimated to be infected with Ascaris lumbricoides and/or hookworm [4, 15]. As part of the national school deworming programme launched in 2012, school children were treated with 400 mg of albendazole in June 2012 and June 2013.

Selection of schools and children

Representative schools of the 90 public primary schools in Bumula District were purposively selected for initial screening with the assistance of the district education and health officials. Initially, 30 schools were screened in January 2013 to identify those schools with highest prevalence of STH infection. Seven schools were excluded because of a low prevalence of STH, with 23 schools recruited into the study. The present study recruited children regardless of infection status, whereas the treatment trial will, in the first instance, recruit only children found to be infected with STH species.

Survey procedures

Parent/guardians of children in class 1–6 were invited to attend sensitization meetings held at the selected schools. The study procedures were explained in a language with which they felt most comfortable, written informed consent was obtained from all parents who were willing to have their children be part of the study before any investigations were done.

Children were asked to provide stool samples which were examined in duplicate for presence of STH eggs by two different technicians using the Kato-Katz method. For the investigation of P. falciparum infections, finger prick blood samples were collected. Thick and thin blood smears were stained with 3 % Giemsa for 45 min and examined by microscopy. Parasite densities were determined from thick blood smears by counting the number of asexual parasites per 200 white blood cells, assuming a white blood cell count of 8,000/μl. A smear was considered negative after reviewing 100 high-powered fields. Thin blood smears were reviewed for species identification. All stool and blood slides were read by two independent microscopists; any discrepancies were resolved by a third microscopist. Ten percent of all samples were re-examined by a senior technician and discrepant (positive versus negative) slides were re-read by a third technician until a consensus was reached. Auxiliary temperature was measured using a digital thermometer and a malaria rapid diagnostic test (SD; Bioline) was performed for all children with fever (auxiliary temperature of <37.5 °C or with a reported history of fever in the previous 24 h). Any participant tested positive for malaria was treated with Coartem (Novartis; 20 mg artemether/120 lumefantrine) in accordance with the national treatment guidelines. Weight was measured to the nearest 0.1 kg using an electronic balance and height was measured to the nearest 0.1 cm using a portable fixed base stadiometer.

Statistical analysis

Anthropometric indices, z-scores of height-for-age (HAZ), weight-for age (WAZ) and body mass index for age (BMIZ) were calculated using the AnthroPlus software for children aged 5–19 years [19]. Age was self-reported and because there were doubts over its precision a mid-year age was assumed. Weight-for-age was calculated only for the children aged 5–10 years. Children were classified as stunted, underweight or thin if their HAZ, WAZ and BMIZ were below −2 standard deviations from the reference medium [19].

The prevalence of each STH species together with the 95 % confidence interval (95 % CI) were calculated using binomial regression analysis taking into account clustering by school. Egg counts of duplicate slide readings were averaged and multiplied by factor 24 to obtain the intensity of infection expressed as eggs per gram (epg) of faeces. To allow for the over dispersed distribution of egg counts arithmetic mean epgs with their 95 % CIs were estimated using negative binomial regression model taking into account school clustering. Infection intensities were also classified into light and moderate to heavy infections according to WHO guidelines [20].

For purposes of this analysis, age was considered as categorical variable (5–8, 9–10, and 11–12 and <14 years), based on observed distribution. To investigate risk factors for P. falciparum infection, mixed effects logistic regression models were fitted taking into account school clustering. First, associations with sex, age (as categorical variable), and nutritional status (classified as underweight, thin or stunted) were investigated in univariable analysis. Explanatory variables significant at (P < 0.20) (based on likelihood ratio test) were considered for the multivariable logistic regression model. Backward-stepwise elimination was used to generate a minimum adequate model, excluded variables (P > 0.05) were retested in the minimum model. Associations between helminth species and Plasmodium infection were investigated using stratified analysis following the Mantel-Haenszel approach adjusting for the potential confounding of sex, age and presence of other helminth species. Overall odds ratios and odds ratios stratified by age and sex, their 95 % confidence intervals (CI) and associated P-value for Mantel-Haenszel χ ² test are reported. Sensitivity analysis was done to compare children without complete data to those with complete data. Statistical analysis was performed using STATA version 12.0 (Stata cooperation, College Station Tx, USA).

Ethical consideration

Ethical approval was provided by the Kenya Medical Research Institute and National Ethics Review Committee (SSC No. 2242), the London School of Hygiene &Tropical Medicine (LSHTM) Ethics Committee (6210), the Makerere School of Public Health, Institutional Review Board (IRB00005876). Prior to the study, school meetings were held during which the purpose and procedures of the study were discussed, parents had the opportunity to ask question, and willing parents were asked to provide written consent for their children to participate.

Results

The 23 schools had an estimated total population of 8,800 of which informed consent was obtained for 7,075 children (80 %). Of these children, 51 did not fulfil the inclusion criteria, 824 were absent on the day of the survey, and 220 children did not either provide a stool sample or an adequate quantity of stool (Fig. 1). Overall, 509 children had missing data on malaria parasitaemia or anthropometric measures, and sensitivity analysis found that children with missing data were more likely to be underweight and thin and infected with P. falciparum, but less likely to be infected with helminth species (Additional file 1: Table S1). The characteristics of included children (n = 5,471) and the prevalence of parasitic infections are shown in Table 1. The mean age of children was 10.5 years (SD, 2.3) and 50.8 % were male. In terms of nutrition status, 3.4 % of children were classified as stunted, 23.9 % of children were underweight and 10.6 % were classified as thin. Underweight and thinness was more common in male than female children (28.9 % vs. 18.7 %, P < 0.001 and 12.8 % vs. 8.6 %, P < 0.001).

Fig. 1

Study flow diagram showing compliance in a cross sectional survey conducted in school children in 23 schools in Bumula District, western Kenya

Table 1 Description of study participants, overall, and by sex. SD = standard deviation, CI = confidence intervals

Single species infection

Overall, 27.6 % of the children were infected with any STH species. The most common species was hookworm (16.9 %), followed by A. lumbricoides (15.3 %); T. trichiura occurred rarely (0.3 %). Infections with multiple helminth species were relatively uncommon (4.7 %) (Table 1). Infection intensity was generally light as per WHO classification; 68 % of the A. lumbricoides and 97 % of the hookworm infections were light infections. Malaria was common: 46.4 % of children were infected with P. falciparum (the only species detected), with the majority of infections being light densities. Infection prevalence and intensity of hookworm and P. falciparum differed by sex, with boys being significantly more infected than girls, while A. lumbricoides and T. trichiura prevalence was comparable between the sexes. Age patterns of prevalence and intensity are shown by species in Fig. 2. The prevalence of A. lumbricoides was highest in children below the age of 9 years while the prevalence of hookworm peaked among children aged 13–18 years. The prevalence of P. falciparum decreased steadily with age (P < 0.001). For all the three species, intensity of infection was generally low and decreased with increasing age apart from hookworm.

Fig. 2

Prevalence (a) and intensity/density (b) of infections by age group among 5471 school children in 23 schools in Bumula District, western Kenya. 95 % confidence intervals were calculated based on binomial and negative binomial regression taking into account school clusters. Intensity was measured in eggs/g faeces for STH species and parasites/μl blood for Plasmodium falciparum

Coinfection

Overall, 14.3 % of children harboured STH-Plasmodium coinfection, with hookworm-Plasmodium coinfection being the most common combination (9.0 %). The prevalence of hookworm-Plasmodium coinfection was also significantly higher in boys than girls, but no sex difference was found in the prevalence of A. lumbricoides-Plasmodium coinfection. The prevalence of A. lumbricoides-Plasmodium coinfection was significantly different among age groups being common in the younger age group (5–8) (P = 0.001), hookworm-Plasmodium coinfection did not vary by age group (P = 0.613).

Geographic distribution of single infections and coinfection

The geographic distribution of single infection and coinfection by school is shown in Fig. 3. P. falciparum was common throughout the study area (range by school, 28.9-69.3 %), with highest prevalence in the western part of the area. The variation in the geographical distribution of STH was more pronounced and varied by species: hookworm was most common in the north-western part of the region (range by school, 7.9-30.0 %), while A. lumbricoides was more common in the eastern area (range by school, 5.8-34.4 %). Coinfection also exhibited geographical variation and coinfection was generally higher in schools with high hookworm or A. lumbricoides prevalence.

Fig. 3

Geographic distribution of STH and Plasmodium falciparum infection and prevalence of STH-Plasmodium coinfections in 23 schools in Bumula District, western Kenya

Factors associated with Plasmodium infection

Table 2 presents the univariable and multivariable analysis of the factors associated with P. falciparum infection and shows that the odds of P. falciparum infection is associated with male sex, and age group. The analysis also provides strong evidence for ensuring association between P. falciparum and hookworm infection and modest evidence for an association between P. falciparum and A. lumbricoides infection. In order to further investigate the associations between helminth species and P. falciparum infections, we performed Mantel-Haenszel stratified analyses. Table 3 presents Mantel-Haenszel stratified (by age group and sex) odds ratios (OR) and indicates that, for boys, the observed association of hookworm and P. falciparum was age dependent, with significantly increased odds among children 5–8 years compared to other age groups. After adjusting for age group and A. lumbricoides infection, hookworm infection was associated with increased odds of Plasmodium infection among both boys (adjusted OR = 1.40, P = 0.0004) and girls (adjusted OR = 1.33, P = 0.01). Mantel-Haenszel stratified analysis for A. lumbricoides and P. falciparum association showed no association by age or sex (Table 4).

Table 2 Univariable and multivariable analysis for association between Plasmodium falciparum infection and potential risk factors among 5471 school children in 23 schools in Bumula District, western Kenya

Table 3 Results of Mantel-Haenszel adjusted odds ratios of the presence of hookworm infection on Plasmodium falciparum infection by sex, adjusting for age and Ascaris lumbricoides infection

Table 4 Results of Mantel-Haenszel adjusted odds ratios of the presence of Ascaris lumbricoides infection on Plasmodium falciparum infection by sex, adjusting for age and hookworm infection

Discussion

An increasing number of STH endemic countries in the world, including Kenya [15], are implementing school-based deworming programmes [21] and this study shows that only a quarter of school children are infected with STH species, whereas studies conducted a decade or more ago suggest that the majority of school-aged children living in western Kenya were infected with STH species [22, 23]. By contrast, malaria parasitaemia remains a common problem among Kenyan school children [16] and as a consequence, we found that 14.3 % of children harboured STH-Plasmodium coinfections, with hookworm-Plasmodium coinfection being the most common coinfection.

As expected, prevalence and density of P. falciparum infection varied by age group. However, patterns of STH infection showed little variation by age, owing perhaps to the relatively low levels of infection. Boys were more likely than girls to be infected with hookworm and P. falciparum, a possible reflection of behavior-related difference in exposure. Patterns of both single species infection and coinfection varied markedly by school and probably reflect a combination of behavioural and socioeconomic factors as well as small scale environmental factors [8, 18, 24, 25].

As shown in previous studies [1, 2, 5, 9, 26], we found an enduring association between hookworm and P. falciparum, after adjusting for age group, sex and presence of other helminth species (Table 4). Interestingly, in Mantel-Haenszel stratified analysis we found no such association between A. lumbricoides and P. falciparum, which is in contrast to previous studies conducted in Madagascar [27, 28] and Thailand [29], which found a negative effect of A. lumbricoides on P. falciparum infection, and a study in Mali which reported a positive association [30].

We recognize a number of limitations in our study. First, diagnosis was based on routine parasitological procedures and acknowledge that expert malaria microscopy may miss light infections when compared to more sensitive molecular methods [31] and that a single stool sample may underestimate the prevalence of helminth infection [32]. Second, the current survey did not collect household information and therefore is subject to potential confounding results. Detailed household-level information was collected only for those children who were found infected and therefore recruited to the main treatment trial (ClinicalTrials.gov NCT01658774), which prevented adjustment for potential confounding in the larger, cross-sectional data set.

Conclusions

In summary, our study showed that helminth-Plasmodium coinfection is not uncommon in western Kenya, despite recent reductions in the prevalence of STH infection due to implementation of a national school-based deworming programme. Our study also corroborates previous studies that have demonstrated positive association between hookworm and P. falciparum. Further longitudinal studies are needed to investigate this association further, the clinical consequences of coinfection, and the impact of anthelminthic treatment on the risks of clinical malaria.